Few chapters in the Bible have sparked more debate than James 2. Verses like “faith without works is dead” (v. 17) and “a man is justified by works, and not by faith only” (v. 24) have led many to wonder whether James is contradicting Paul’s teaching that we are saved by faith alone (Romans 4:5; Ephesians 2:8–9).
But here’s the good news: Paul and James are not enemies. They are teammates addressing different issues. Paul explains how a sinner is justified before God — by faith alone in Christ. James teaches how a believer’s faith is vindicated before others — by works that make faith visible.
1. The Sin of Partiality (James 2:1–13)
James begins with the problem of favoritism in the church. Imagine a wealthy visitor being ushered into the best seat while a poor man is told to stand in the back. James calls this evil because it contradicts the faith we hold in “the Lord of glory” (v. 1).
God often chooses the poor of this world to be rich in faith (v. 5). To despise them is to dishonor God’s values. Instead, believers are called to fulfill the “royal law” — love your neighbor as yourself (v. 8).
James reminds us that at the final judgment, “mercy triumphs over judgment” (v. 13). Therefore, we are urged to live mercifully now.
Takeaway: Favoritism reflects worldly values. Mercy reflects Christlike love.
2. The Profit of Living Faith (James 2:14–20)
Next, James asks: “What does it profit… if someone says he has faith but does not have works? Can faith save him?” (v. 14).
The key word here is profit. James is not questioning whether faith alone saves eternally. That has already been settled by Christ’s finished work. Instead, he is asking: What benefit is there to others if our professed faith never acts?
He illustrates with a hungry brother or sister. To say, “Be warmed and filled” without actually giving food is useless (vv. 15–16). In the same way, faith without works is “dead” — not false, but barren, inactive, and unproductive when it comes to helping others (v. 17).
Faith is invisible. Works make it visible (v. 18). Even demons believe propositional truths about God, yet believing these facts alone produces nothing (v. 19). Likewise, a believer’s faith that never moves into action remains fruitless for both the church and the watching world.
Takeaway: Faith without works certainly exists, but it cannot commend us to one another or demonstrate itself in the sight of others.
3. Faith Vindicated by Works (James 2:21–26)
James then points to two Old Testament examples.
- Abraham was justified before God by faith in Genesis 15:6. But years later, when he offered Isaac (Genesis 22), his faith was “made perfect” — matured and brought to completion. That act vindicated his faith before others (vv. 21–23).
- Rahab believed in Israel’s God before she hid the spies (Joshua 2:9–11). Her actions simply demonstrated her faith to others (v. 25).
James concludes: “As the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also” (v. 26). A body without the spirit is still a body — but lifeless. Likewise, faith without works is still faith — but barren when it comes to bearing witness among others.
Takeaway: Works cannot create saving faith. They do, however, bring faith into public focus, making us visible as believers motivated by Christ’s love to serve one another.
Bringing It All Together
James 2 does not contradict Paul — it complements him.
- Paul’s emphasis: Justification before God — by faith alone.
- James’ emphasis: Justification before others — by works that demonstrate faith.
Faith alone saves eternally. But faith without works is fruitless, unprofitable, and ultimately ineffective in blessing others.
How This Speaks to Us Today
- For believers: Eternal salvation is secure through Christ. But your testimony and effectiveness in serving others are shaped by how you live. We never look to our works to commend us to God — salvation is entirely the work of Christ. Yet without visible works, it is difficult to be “justified” before others in the community of faith.
- For the church: Guard against favoritism. See people as Christ does, not by worldly standards.
- For witness: Faith in action validates the gospel to a watching world.
- For eternity: Works do not save, for Christians are justified by Christ’s atoning work alone. But works are the natural and appropriate response of a renewed heart, the fruit of living faith shaped by God’s love in Christ.
Final Word
Eternal salvation is secure in Christ alone. No other foundation can be laid than that which is laid in Christ Jesus. Justification before God is accomplished by Christ’s work alone, forever settled by His blood.
But James urges us: Do not let your faith lie dormant like a fallow field yielding no harvest. Put it to work in love, mercy, and obedience — for the sake of your brothers and sisters in the church, and for the sake of those God may yet call to repentance.
Because faith alone saves — but faith expressed in works blesses others and brings glory to God.
Jason Boothe is a Pastor at Redeemer Church of Piketon, Ohio.
Discover more from Redeemer Church
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Redeemer Church 